Dernière mise à jour: 2026-05-01
Expecting a Return Gift of Equal Value : est-ce haram ?
Réponse rapide
Non — Expecting a Return Gift of Equal Value : permitted — the sunnah itself reciprocates gifts, and hoping a kindness is answered is human; disliked to sinful when the expectation curdles into demand, resentment, or taking the gift back — the one who gives only to extract the like has traded the akhirah’s reward for the market’s selon l'islam.
IsItASin · Dernière mise à jour:
Non — Expecting a Return Gift of Equal Value : permitted — the sunnah itself reciprocates gifts, and hoping a kindness is answered is human; disliked to sinful when the expectation curdles into demand, resentment, or taking the gift back — the one who gives only to extract the like has traded the akhirah’s reward for the market’s selon l'islam. Hadith (Bukhari) — the Prophet accepted gifts and gave in return — reciprocity is sunnah, not obligation.
Ce que l'islam enseigne sur Expecting a Return Gift of Equal Value
Selon l'islam, Expecting a Return Gift of Equal Value : permitted — the sunnah itself reciprocates gifts, and hoping a kindness is answered is human; disliked to sinful when the expectation curdles into demand, resentment, or taking the gift back — the one who gives only to extract the like has traded the akhirah’s reward for the market’s.
Islamic teaching stands on two hadith that frame the whole matter: reciprocity is praised — 'exchange gifts, you will love one another' (Tirmidhi), and the Prophet 'used to accept a gift and give something in return' (Bukhari) — so answering a gift with one is sunnah, and the scholars note the return should be, when possible, the better of the two. But the obligation runs one way only: 'whoever gives a gift and then takes it back is like the dog that eats and returns to its vomit' (Bukhari; Ibn Majah) — the hiba, once given, is in the strong classical opinion irrevocable, creating gratitude owed to Allah for the chance to give, not a debt owed by the receiver. The Qur'an names the only ledger the believer is invited to keep: 'lend to Allah a goodly loan' (Qur'an 2:245) — the return comes from Him, multiplied, at a time He chooses — and the model of expectation-free giving is the verse about the believers' table: 'we feed you, seeking the countenance of Allah; we wish not from you reward or thanks' (Qur'an 76:9). So the fiqh line is intention and aftermath: giving in the hope the friendship answers in kind is mubah and lovely; giving in order to compel, then resenting, demanding, or reclaiming when it does not, degrades the gift into a concealed qard — and the concealed qard, unlike the declared one, has no terms and no forgiveness built in. Declare the loan where a loan was meant; let the gift be free where a gift was given.
Vous vous demandez ce qu'enseignent les autres religions ?
The Study Quran
For questions this important, going back to the source matters. The Study Quran — the definitive English translation with 1,500+ pages of commentary by leading scholars — provides the depth these questions deserve.
Références Coraniques
- Hadith (Bukhari) — the Prophet accepted gifts and gave in return — reciprocity is sunnah, not obligation.
- Hadith (Bukhari; Ibn Majah) — whoever takes back his gift is like the dog returning to its vomit — the gift creates no collectible debt.
- Hadith (Tirmidhi) — exchange gifts, you will love one another — the answer to a gift is love, not invoice.
- Qur'an 76:9 — we feed you, seeking Allah's countenance, not reward or thanks from you — the model of expectation-free giving.
- Qur'an 2:245 — lend to Allah a goodly loan — the only ledger kept is with Allah, and He repays multiplied.
Book of Repentance (Sahih Muslim)
The Prophet (peace be upon him) said Allah rejoices more when you return than a man who finds water in the desert. Islamic tradition holds that tawbah is always accepted for those who sincerely seek it.
Begin Your Tawbah — The Path Is Open →Sujets liés
Avertissement : IsItASin.org propose des synthèses d'information sur les enseignements religieux de plusieurs traditions. Il ne s'agit pas d'un conseil religieux. Pour un accompagnement spirituel personnel, consultez un guide religieux qualifié de votre tradition.