Zuletzt aktualisiert: 2026-10-05
Weinen im Gottesdienst: Ist es Haram?
Kurzantwort
Nein, Weinen im Gottesdienst gilt im Islam als Mustahabb (empfohlen).
IsItASin · Zuletzt aktualisiert: 2026-10-05
Nein, Weinen im Gottesdienst gilt im Islam als Mustahabb (empfohlen). Sunan al-Tirmidhi — 'Two eyes will not be touched by the Fire: an eye that wept from fear of Allah, and an eye that spent the night guarding in Allah's path.'
Was Islam über Weinen im Gottesdienst lehrt
Im Islam gilt Weinen im Gottesdienst als Mustahabb (empfohlen).
Das Weinen im Gebet – besonders aus Furcht vor Allah oder aus Ehrfurcht – wird gepriesen: Der Prophet sagte, zwei Augen werde das Feuer nicht berühren – ein Auge, das aus Furcht vor Allah weinte, und ein Auge, das wach blieb, um Seinen Weg zu hüten. Der Prophet selbst weinte im Gebet, und die Rezitation Ibn Umars eines Verses über die Berge brachte die Zuhörer zu Tränen.
Sie möchten wissen, was andere Religionen lehren?
The Study Quran
For questions this important, going back to the source matters. The Study Quran — the definitive English translation with 1,500+ pages of commentary by leading scholars — provides the depth these questions deserve.
Was Islam über Weinen im Gottesdienst lehrt
Vollständige Antwort (auf Englisch) — Die ausführliche Analyse unten ist auf Englisch verfügbar. Vollständige englische Version lesen →
Islam has an unusually specific eschatology of the weeping eye. The hadith: 'two eyes will not be touched by the Fire — an eye that wept from fear of Allah, and an eye that spent the night guarding in Allah's cause' (Tirmidhi) — tears as fire-insurance, in the tradition's vivid register. The Quran itself describes the righteous response to revelation: when the verses of the Most Merciful were recited, 'they fell in prostration, weeping' (19:58) — the early community's worship included audible emotion, and the Prophet wept in prayer until his beard was wet (the recitation of a verse about the Day of Judgment, per Aisha's narration in Muslim). The category of khushu — humble, tender attentiveness in prayer — is the intended interior state, and scholars note that tears are its natural fruit, not a distraction from it: the heart present before God softens, and softened hearts leak. The cautions mirror the other traditions' — performative weeping for reputation contradicts the hiddenness of sincere worship, and despairing grief ('wrongs about Allah's mercy') is rebuked — but the worshiper who cries from awe stands in the Quran's own portrait of the believers.
Koranische Verweise
- Sunan al-Tirmidhi — 'Two eyes will not be touched by the Fire: an eye that wept from fear of Allah, and an eye that spent the night guarding in Allah's path.'
- Quran 19:58 — 'When the verses of the Most Merciful were recited to them, they fell in prostration weeping.'
- Sahih al-Bukhari — The Prophet wept during prayer, and on holding his grandson at the brink of death, said: The eye tears, the heart grieves, but we say only what pleases our Lord.'
Was Sie tun sollten
Die ausführliche Analyse unten ist auf Englisch verfügbar.
- If tears come in worship, let them — you are in the Psalms' and the Prophet's company.
- If they never come, do not perform them; worship in dryness is still worship.
- Muslim: Seek khushu — tender presence — and remember the two eyes the Fire will not touch.
- All: If tears are grief rather than devotion, let the community in — pastors, imams, and rabbis are for exactly that.
Book of Repentance (Sahih Muslim)
The Prophet (peace be upon him) said Allah rejoices more when you return than a man who finds water in the desert. Islamic tradition holds that tawbah is always accepted for those who sincerely seek it.
Begin Your Tawbah — The Path Is Open →Häufige Fragen
Die ausführliche Analyse unten ist auf Englisch verfügbar.
Is crying during prayer a sign of weakness or holiness?
The traditions answer with one voice: neither weakness nor automatic holiness — it is simply the heart's overflow, praised when it flows from awe, repentance, or love.
The traditions answer with one voice: neither weakness nor automatic holiness — it is simply the heart's overflow, praised when it flows from awe, repentance, or love. What is judged is the heart, never the tear ducts.
What if I feel nothing in worship?
Dryness is a standard chapter in every tradition's spiritual literature.
Dryness is a standard chapter in every tradition's spiritual literature. Faithfulness in dryness is often rated above consolation in fervor. Keep the practice; talk with a spiritual director; the tears return.
Is emotional worship manipulative?
It can be — when engineered for display or proof of spirituality.
It can be — when engineered for display or proof of spirituality. Every tradition here condemns performance while honoring genuine emotion. Test: does the emotion draw you toward God and neighbor, or toward the mirror?
Verwandte Themen
Hinweis: IsItASin.org bietet informative Zusammenfassungen religiöser Lehren verschiedener Traditionen. Dies ist keine religiöse Beratung. Für persönliche geistliche Begleitung wenden Sie sich an eine qualifizierte religiöse Führungskraft Ihrer Tradition.