Última atualização: 2026-11-02
Under-Scanning Items at Self-Checkout · Catholic
Catholic · grave-sin-if-deliberate-and-repeated
Catholic moral theology distinguishes the deliberate mis-scan (theft, matter of the seventh commandment, grave by the amount taken) from mechanical error, which obliges correction once noticed (Catechism 2408-2409). Because the small amounts repeat, the habitual under-scanner accumulates serious matter quickly; restitution to the store is required and is the condition of absolution for substantial takings.
Catechism of the Catholic Church 2408-2409
Resposta completa (em inglês)
Referências {scripture}
- Ephesians 4:28 — 'he who has been stealing must steal no longer' — the plain rule for the mis-scanner.
- Joshua 7 — Achan's hidden taking brought loss on all Israel — small thefts are never private.
- Malachi 3:8 — robbing when no collector watches — self-checkout is the unwatched till.
- Leviticus 6:1-5 — restitution required — the honest error must be repaid, not shrugged.
Under-Scanning Items at Self-Checkout · Quer saber o que outras religiões ensinam?
Protestant churches
sin-grave-when-habitual
The Reformed confessions read the eighth commandment to include 'all unjust means of gaining our neighbor's goods' (Heidelberg 110) — the unscanned item is gained unjustly whatever the cashier interface allowed. Deliberateness before God, who sees the basket as well as the heart, removes every defense of convenience. Restitution and honest re-scanning habits are the repentance the commandment demands.
Eastern Orthodox Church
grave-sin-when-deliberate
Halakha is unambiguous: one who leaves a store without paying for what he holds owes the debt whether or not he was caught (Choshen Mishpat), and deliberate under-charging is geneivah — theft — not oversight. The Talmud's honest merchant standard (Bava Metzia on ona'ah) requires the customer as much as the seller to keep exchanges true. A running habit of 'missed' scans is a scheme of theft, and the accumulated gain must be restored to the store.