Dernière mise à jour: 2026-11-02
Passing Off AI-Generated Work as Human-Made to Clients · Protestant
Protestant · sinful
Protestant ethics reads the case under the ninth commandment: the invoice and the conversation about the work constitute testimony, and false testimony about provenance is false witness (Exodus 20:16) even when the product itself is serviceable. Christian vocation teaching holds that work is done 'as for the Lord' (Colossians 3:23), which forbids presenting as one's diligence what one's tool produced under a label that hides it. Honest disclosure of AI assistance, priced accordingly, removes the sin while keeping the tool.
Holy Bible (Protestant canon); Exodus 20; Colossians 3
Réponse complète (en anglais)
Références {scripture}
- Colossians 3:9 — 'do not lie to one another' — the false account of the work's origin.
- Leviticus 19:11 — 'you shall not steal or deal falsely' — craft price taken for machine goods.
- Proverbs 11:1 — 'a false balance is an abomination' — the mislabeled deliverable.
- Matthew 5:37 — 'let your yes be yes' — the contract honored as spoken.
Passing Off AI-Generated Work as Human-Made to Clients · Vous vous demandez ce qu'enseignent les autres religions ?
Catholic Church
venial-sin-usually-grave-when-fraud
Catholic moral theology treats fraud (Catechism 2409) and lying (2482) as distinct sins that here coincide: the deliverable is misdescribed and the description is false. Where a single small commission is mislabeled the matter is venial; where the practice is systematic, the sums substantial, or clients include those who rely on the maker's accountability — a business buying 'original' copy, a publisher buying human illustration — it becomes grave. Restitution means refunding the difference between what was promised and what was delivered (2487) and correcting the record with the client.
Eastern Orthodox Church
Péché
Orthodox teaching binds every Christian to truthfulness as the image of Christ who is the Truth; a seller who misdescribes his goods confesses with his mouth while denying it with his invoice. The canons treat fraud in sale (cf. Basil's canonical letters on dishonest gain) as requiring restitution, not merely regret. The machine's assistance is not at issue — the ascetic tradition blesses every legitimate tool — but the false account of the work steals the client's judgment and must be confessed and corrected.