Dernière mise à jour: 2026-11-02
Taking Trade Secrets or Client Lists to a New Employer · Catholic
Catholic · grave matter when the value is significant or the trust was explicit
The Catechism treats unjustly keeping and using another's goods as theft (CCC 2409) and requires faithfulness to contracted commitments (CCC 2410–2411). Employment contracts and confidentiality undertakings make the moral line explicit: taking client data on exit breaks both justice and fidelity. Because firms suffer real, provable damage — lost clients, lost advantage, sometimes the firm's viability — the matter is normally grave, requiring confession and amendment before communion. Restitution is difficult but owed: destroy the material, inform the new employer so the advantage is not used, and accept the professional cost as part of reparation.
Catechism of the Catholic Church 2409, 2410, 2411
Réponse complète (en anglais)
Références {scripture}
- Luke 16:10–12 — faithful in that which is another's — the confidential file is another's property on trust.
- Exodus 20:15 — you shall not steal — information owned by the employer is included in 'not yours.'
- Exodus 20:17 — you shall not covet — the competitor's edge desired and taken belongs to another.
- Titus 2:9–10 — not pilfering, but showing all good faith — the departing download is pilfering by inbox.
Taking Trade Secrets or Client Lists to a New Employer · Vous vous demandez ce qu'enseignent les autres religions ?
Protestant churches
Péché
Protestant conscience names the modern disguise: 'everyone keeps their contacts; it's just smart career management.' But the contacts were earned on the employer's payroll for the employer's purposes; keeping them for the next bidder is keeping what was another's. Vocation teaching holds that work itself is ministry — and ministry cannot be advanced by stolen tools. The same Paul who told servants not to pilfer told thieves to work with their own hands (Ephesians 4:28): the career built on a rival's secrets is built on taking, not giving. Repentance is concrete: delete the data, disclose the breach where required, and win the new job on what you can honestly offer.
Eastern Orthodox Church
Péché
Orthodox teaching treats entrusted things as a testing ground for the soul: the one who keeps faith in small confidences is being trained for greater faithfulness to God. Saint John Climacus places the love of gain among the passions that corrupt even the capable and gifted — the talented employee's talent makes the betrayal possible and therefore more blameworthy. The Fathers' counsel on stolen goods is unchanging: restore what was taken, and add to it. For information, restoration means destruction of the copies and refusal to profit from the knowledge; confession must name the betrayal as betrayal, not as a career move.