Zuletzt aktualisiert: 2026-11-02
Recording Houseguests With Smart Speakers or Cameras Without Telling Them · Orthodox
Orthodox · sin-grave-when-shared-or-exploited
Jewish law protects a person's expectation of privacy in another's domain — the Talmud (Bava Batra) restricts what a householder may do that harms those who rely on his premises; and the law of eavesdropping (chushad — one who peers where he should not) treats the gathered confidence as tainted. Hospitality in rabbinic tradition (hachnasat orchim) is praised above welcoming the Divine presence; turning the guest room into a listening post is its inversion. The recordings of unwitting guests must be deleted and, where harm was possible, disclosed.
Talmud Bava Batra; rabbinic teaching on hachnasat orchim
Vollständige Antwort (auf Englisch)
{scripture} Verweise
- Hebrews 13:2 — hospitality to strangers — the host's duty is service, not surveillance.
- Genesis 18 — Abraham serves his guests openly — hospitality as honored trust.
- Matthew 5:37 — 'let your yes be yes' — transparency governs what a room hears.
- Leviticus 19:16 — do not stand against the blood of your neighbor — hidden knowledge used against the unwitting.
Recording Houseguests With Smart Speakers or Cameras Without Telling Them · Sie möchten wissen, was andere Religionen lehren?
Catholic Church
sin-grave-when-recordings-are-used-or-shared
Catholic teaching on privacy (Catechism 2489 on the duty of discretion in communication; 1738 on the right to be let alone) extends to the guest whose presence in a home is itself an act of trust. Recording without knowledge violates that trust; the gravity rises with the intimacy of what is captured and the use made of it — a kept archive of guests' private words is a matter requiring confession, and deletion of the recordings is part of restitution.
Protestant churches
sin-usually-not-grave-if-benign-and-undisclosed-but-sin
The ninth commandment's demand for truth-telling (Heidelberg 112) covers the host's silent lie: by not disclosing, the host lets every guest believe he is unobserved. Even where the intent is benign, the capture is of words offered in trusted confidence, and Scripture ties safeguarding to the neighbor's good (Romans 15:2). Disclosure is the minimal duty; consent, not convenience, decides what may be kept.